Skip to content

Over One Billion Recovered

Free Confidential Case Review, No Fees Unless We Recover For You

Call Us Today, 24/7: 212-779-0057

Hach & Rose, LLP Logo
  • The Firm
    • About Us
    • Meet Our Team
    • News
    • FAQs
    • Press Releases
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury
      • Car Accidents
      • Truck Accidents
      • Motorcycle Accidents
      • New York City Premises Liability Lawyers
      • Slip and Fall Accidents
      • New York City Nursing Home Abuse Lawyers
      • Brain Injuries
      • Neck and Back Injuries
      • Scooter Accidents
      • New York City Fire and Explosion Injury Lawyer
      • FELA/Railroad Worker Injuries
      • New York City Rental Bike Accident Lawyer
      • Sexual Abuse
      • New York City Tourist Injury Lawyer
      • Work Injuries
      • Wrongful Death
      • See All Personal Injury Practice Areas
    • Mass Tort Cases
      • 9/11 Victim Compensation
      • Social Media Harm
      • Ozempic Lawsuit
      • Video Game Addiction
      • Discord Lawsuits
      • Pacemaker Recall Lawsuit
      • Talcum Powder Lawsuit
      • Baby Formula Lawsuit
      • Hotel Sex Trafficking Lawsuit
      • Asbestos
      • See All Defective Drugs & Products
    • Construction Injuries
      • Construction Accidents
      • Representation for Union Members
      • FELA / Railroad Worker Injury
      • See All Work Related Injuries
    • Employment Law
      • Employment Contract Review
      • Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) Lawyer
      • Severance Agreements
      • Wage Theft
      • Whistleblower Defense
      • Workplace Harassment
      • Wrongful Termination
    • Social Security Disability
    • Sexual Abuse
  • Video FAQs
  • Testimonials
  • Results
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Search
Get a free consultation

Can A Pre-Existing Injury Affect Your Personal Injury Claim?

Home  >  New York City Personal Injury Lawyer   >  Can A Pre-Existing Injury Affect Your Personal Injury Claim?

Quite often, we are faced with a situation that a client injured a body part that had been hurt before. Typically, these people have back injuries or other physical injuries that occurred in the past that are reinjured in an accident caused by someone else’s negligent act.  Insurance companies and people who defend lawsuits assume that the prior injury is a reason a claim is less valuable. This is not true. To the extent that an injury is made worse as a result of the negligent acts of another person, the victim is entitled to recover to the extent that the prior injury is aggravated or made worse. Bottom line: if someone is liable, they do not get a discount just because they had a preexisting injury. If you were injured before and worked hard to get better, then you should be admired for your desire to get better, not penalized because you were hurt before.

Prior Injuries May Not Affect Your Personal Injury Claim

Some of the best results our firm has obtained over the years have been for people who aggravated pre-existing conditions due to a defendant’s negligence. My first multi-million dollar jury verdict was on behalf of a man who injured his back in a car accident. He had been in another car accident and injured his back years before. He clearly aggravated his back injury in the second accident. However, the defense attorney and the insurance company responsible for evaluating the case did not offer a fair settlement based on the defense that my client had a prior injury. The JURY THOUGHT DIFFERENTLY!

A Six Figure Settlement

We also had a client who injured his back on a construction site. He received a six-figure settlement as a result of this accident. He rehabilitated himself, and through hard work with his doctors, he returned to work. While on a construction site, he was injured again. He received a multi-million dollar settlement because he aggravated his preexisting injury in that second accident. In my view, when people were hurt before, their cases are often worth more money. Because the prior injury or condition makes them more susceptible to a more significant injury the second time around.

Call Our Personal Injury Lawyers

At Hach & Rose, LLP, we fight hard for those with aggravated prior injuries. We would not give negligent parties or insurance companies discounts if you were hurt before. If you had a prior injury, never believe you are entitled to anything less than a full and fair recovery. We take pride in hiring the proper medical experts who can explain why a person with a pre-existing injury is more susceptible to injury and who can differentiate between the individual’s pre-accident status and how they were made worse due to trauma. This entitles our clients to full recovery. For a free consultation on all personal injury matters, call Hach & Rose, LLP at 212-779-0057 

Schedule Your Consultation

Practice Areas

  • Manhattan Rideshare Accident Lawyer
  • Manhattan Construction Accident Lawyer
  • Bronx Rideshare Accident Lawyer
  • Bronx Construction Accident Lawyer
  • Manhattan Pedestrian Accident Lawyer
  • Brooklyn Construction Accident Lawyer
  • Brooklyn Pedestrian Accident Lawyer
  • Brooklyn Rideshare Accident Lawyer
  • Bronx Pedestrian Accident Lawyer
  • Bronx Truck Accident Lawyer
  • Brooklyn Truck Accident Lawyer
  • Bronx Premises Liability Lawyer
  • Brooklyn Premises Liability Lawyer
  • Bronx Slip and Fall Lawyer
  • Brooklyn Slip and Fall Lawyer
  • New York City Premises Liability Lawyers
  • New York City Dog Bite Lawyers
  • New York City Truck Accident Lawyers
  • New York City Slip and Fall Lawyers
  • New York Sexual Abuse Lawyer
  • New York City Rental Bike Accident Lawyer
  • New York City Tourist Injury Lawyer
  • New York City Car Accident Lawyers
  • Depo Provera Lawsuit
  • New York Social Security Disability Attorney
  • New York Union Worker Injury Lawyer
  • Defective Drugs & Products
  • New York City Work Injury Lawyers
  • New York City Fire and Explosion Injury Lawyer
  • New York City Motorcycle Accident Lawyers
  • New York City E-Scooter Accident Lawyers
  • Staten Island Car Accident Lawyer
  • New York City Train Accident Lawyers
  • New York City Subway Accident Lawyers
  • New York City Wrongful Death Lawyers
  • Asbestos
  • California School Sexual Abuse Lawsuit
  • Olympus Scope (Endoscope/Duodenoscope) Lawsuit
  • Social Media Harm Lawsuits
  • Brooklyn Car Accident Lawyers
  • Queens Car Accident Lawyers
  • Bronx Car Accident Lawyers
  • Manhattan Car Accident Lawyers
  • New York City Neck and Back Injury Lawyers
  • Snapchat Lawsuit
  • Dupixent Lawsuit
  • New York Wage and Hour Attorney
  • New York City Employment Discrimination Attorney
  • New York City Workplace Sexual Harassment Attorney
  • New York Whistleblower Attorney
  • New York Wrongful Termination Lawyers
  • New York City Rideshare Accident Lawyers
  • New York City Severance Agreement Lawyers
  • Hotel Sex Trafficking Lawsuit
  • New York City Employment Contract Review Lawyers
  • New York City Bicycle Accident Lawyers
  • New York City Negligent Child Supervision Lawyers
  • New York City FELA Railroad Injury Lawyers
  • New York City Federal Railroad Safety Act (FRSA) Lawyers
  • New York Wage Theft Attorney
  • New York Wage Theft Act Lawyer
  • New York Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) Lawyer
  • Discord Lawsuits
  • Hair Straightener Uterine Cancer Lawsuit
  • Toxic Baby Food Lawsuit Attorneys
  • New York City Pedestrian Accident Lawyers
  • Firefighting Foam (AFFF) Lawyer in NYC
  • Suboxone Lawsuit
  • Baby Formula Lawsuits
  • New York City Unsafe Equipment Lawyers
  • New York City Forklift Accident Lawyers
  • New York City Falling Object Accident Lawyers
  • Zantac Lawsuit
  • Window Washing Accident Lawyer NYC
  • New York City Elevator Accident Lawyers
  • Northwell Health Secret Videotaping Lawyers
  • New York Construction Accident Lawyer
  • Tylenol Autism Lawsuits
  • Oxbryta
  • BioZorb Lawsuit Attorney in New York
  • Wegovy Lawsuit Attorney in New York
  • Mounjaro Lawsuit Attorney in New York
  • Paragard IUD Lawsuit Attorney in New York
  • Video Game Addiction
  • Bard PowerPort Lawsuit
  • Nowojorski prawnik ds. obrażeń ciała
  • Boston Scientific Accolade Pacemaker Recall Lawsuit
  • New York City Mass Tort Lawyers
  • New York City Nursing Home Abuse Lawyers
  • Illinois Juvenile Detention Centers
  • Premises Liability & Slip and Fall Lawyers
  • New York City Trip and Fall Lawyers
  • PFAS Lawsuits
  • IVF Contamination Lawsuit Attorneys
  • Roundup
  • 9/11 Victim Compensation Lawyer in NYC
  • Ozempic Lawsuit Attorneys
  • New York City Motorcycle Crash Driver Error Lawyers
  • New York City Road Defect Motorcycle Accident Lawyers
  • New York City Drunk Driver Motorcycle Accident Lawyers
  • Adult Survivors of Childhood Sexual Abuse Lawyers in Pennsylvania
  • New York Overweight Load Lawyers
  • New York City Driver Error Accident Lawyers
  • Rideshare Sexual Assault Lawyer
  • Sex Trafficking Attorneys
  • Ezricare Artificial Tears Lawsuit 
  • New York City Aggressive Truck Driving Accident Lawyers
  • New York City Road Condition Truck Accident Lawyers
  • Bus Accidents
  • Paraquat Lawsuit
  • New York City Hit and Run Lawyers
  • Brooklyn Police Misconduct Lawyers
  • New York City Bedsore Lawyers
  • New York City Laceration Injury Lawyers
  • Revive Smoothie Tara Flour Poisoning
  • New York City Psychological Injury Lawyers
  • New York City Electrocution Lawyers
  • Attorneys for Internal Bleeding or Organ Failure from a Construction Accident
  • New York Burns Suffered in Car Accidents Lawyer
  • Daily Harvest Recall – Food Poisoning Lawsuit
  • Camp Lejeune Water Contamination Lawsuit Attorneys
  • Child Sex Abuse Survivor Support Law Firm
  • New York City Drowsy Driving Accident Lawyers
  • New York City Disfigurement Car Accident Lawyers
  • New York City Housing Authority (NYCHA) Negligence Lawyers
  • New York City Speeding Accident Lawyers
  • New York City Tailgating Accident Lawyers
  • New York City Car Seat Ejection Lawyers
  • New York City Loss of Limb Car Accident Lawyers
  • New York City Crush Injury Lawyers
  • New York City Paralysis Car Accident Lawyers
  • Car Accidents
  • Premises Liability
  • New York Soft Tissue Injuries from Car Accidents Lawyers
  • New York City Internal Bleeding Car Accident Lawyers
  • Benzene Lawsuits
  • New York City Concussion Car Accident Lawyers
  • Toxic Substance Exposure
  • New York City CRPS Injury Lawyers
  • Workers’ Rights
  • Class Actions
  • Talcum Powder
  • New York City Child Victims Act Lawyers
  • New Jersey Child Sex Abuse Law
  • New York City Medical Malpractice Lawyers
  • New York City Aviation Accident Lawyers
  • Car Accidents
  • Queens Ladder Accidents
  • Queens Slip-and-Fall
  • New York City Brain Injury Lawyers
  • Traumatic Brain Injuries And Altered Consciousness
  • Electrical Hazards at Construction Sites
  • Automotive Manufacturers Recall Requirements
  • New York City Spinal Cord Injury Lawyers
  • Boy Scout Abuse Lawsuits
  • New York City Ladder Accident Lawyers
  • New York City Right to Return Lawyers
  • New York City Nursing Home Neglect Lawyers
  • Electronic Cigarettes
  • Foster Care
  • New York City Nursing Home Dehydration Lawyers
  • New York City Nursing Home Fall Lawyers
  • New York City Knee Injury Lawyers
  • New York City Eye Injury Lawyers
  • New York City Crane Accident Lawyers
  • Failed Knee Replacement Surgery Lawyer
  • Workers’ Compensation and No-Fault Ramifications

Hach & Rose, LLP Logo If you've been injured in an accident or on the job, the attorneys of Hach & Rose, LLP have the knowledge, skills, and experience required to hold the party responsible for your injury accountable.

Areas Served: Bronx, Brooklyn, Bushwick, Brooklyn Heights, Central Harlem, East Harlem, East Village, Financial District, Greenpoint, Forest Hills, Harlem, Howard Beach, Jackson Heights, Long Island, Lower East Side, Lower Manhattan, Manhattan, Midtown, New Jersey, Rego Park, Soho, Tribeca, Upper East Side, Upper Manhattan, Upper West Side, West Side, West Harlem

Main Office

Hach & Rose, LLP

112 Madison Ave 10th floor,
New York, NY 10016
212-779-0057

Schedule Your Free Consultation

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Consent agreement


  • The Firm
  • Practice Areas
  • Video FAQs
  • Testimonials
  • Results
  • Blog
  • Contact

© 2026 Hach & Rose, LLP. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Sitemap