Our NYC subway accident lawyers represent passengers and others who were seriously injured due to unsafe subway trains, platforms, stairways, stations, and transit operations. We determine who controlled the equipment or the dangerous condition, preserve surveillance and maintenance evidence, comply with special procedures that may apply to transit claims, and pursue responsible parties through settlement or trial.
Subway cases are different from ordinary accident claims. An injury may involve the New York City Transit Authority, another public entity, a contractor, or a private property owner, and identifying the correct defendant can affect both liability and deadlines for taking legal action.
At Hach & Rose, LLP, we have recovered more than $1 billion for injured clients. We are a New York trial firm, not a settlement mill. When a serious subway injury case cannot be resolved fairly, our attorneys are prepared to present the evidence to a jury.
Call (212) 779-0057 for a free, confidential consultation. Our team is available 24/7, and consultations are offered in English and Spanish.
SCHEDULE A CONSULTATION
When Can You Bring a Claim After an NYC Subway Accident?
You may have a personal injury claim when negligence by a transit authority, contractor, property owner, or another party causes an unsafe condition or incident that results in your injuries.
Subway accidents happen in many different ways. Some occur aboard moving trains. Others involve defective station infrastructure or hazardous conditions encountered while entering, leaving, or waiting for a train.
Potential cases include injuries caused by:
- Sudden or unusual train movements, collisions, or derailments
- Malfunctioning subway doors or other equipment
- Broken stairs, handrails, platforms, or station infrastructure
- Slippery walking surfaces, inadequate lighting, or unrepaired hazards
- Construction, maintenance, or contractor negligence within stations
The existence of a dangerous condition alone does not establish liability. Our attorneys investigate who created or controlled the hazard, what that party knew or should have known, and whether reasonable measures could have prevented the injury.
Who Can Be Held Responsible for a New York City Subway Injury?
Liability depends on the specific location, equipment, people, and entities involved in the accident. The New York City Transit Authority (NYCTA) operates New York City's subway system as part of the broader MTA network. A claim involving train operations, subway equipment, or station conditions requires careful identification of the public entity legally responsible for the incident.
Other defendants may also be involved. For example, contractors perform construction, repair, cleaning, and maintenance work throughout the subway system. An unsafe condition created during that work may lead to contractor liability.
Certain station entrances or areas connected to private buildings can also raise questions about whether a private property owner is responsible for the location. A serious case can therefore require examination of contracts, maintenance responsibilities, work records, property boundaries, employee actions, and control over the area where the injury occurred.
Why the First 90 Days are Important After a Subway Accident
One of the most important differences between a subway injury claim and an ordinary negligence lawsuit is the potential requirement to file a Notice of Claim. Under New York General Municipal Law § 50-e, when an injury claim against a public corporation requires a Notice of Claim, it generally must be served within 90 days after the claim arises.
This is substantially shorter than New York's ordinary three-year personal injury statute of limitations. The correct deadline depends on which public authority or other entity is being sued, so injured passengers should not assume they have three years simply because that is the deadline associated with many New York negligence cases.
There is another practical reason to act quickly: evidence from a subway accident can disappear quickly. Surveillance recordings may not be preserved indefinitely. A spill can be cleaned. Broken equipment can be repaired. Construction conditions change. Employees and witnesses move on.
Contacting our team quickly allows us to begin our investigation while evidence of the accident is still available. Reach out today to learn more about how we can help.
SCHEDULE A CONSULTATIONHow Hach & Rose, LLP Investigates a Subway Injury
Subway accident cases can turn on evidence that an injured passenger cannot obtain independently. Our attorneys begin by identifying the precise location and circumstances of the accident, including the station, platform, staircase, train line, train car, direction of travel, approximate time, and any employees or contractors involved.
From there, potentially important evidence may include surveillance footage, incident reports, maintenance and inspection records, repair histories, photographs, witness testimony, employee records, construction documentation, and medical evidence.
Consider a fall on a subway staircase. A photograph may show a broken step, but it does not necessarily establish how long the defect existed or who was responsible for repairing it. Maintenance records, prior complaints, inspection histories, or evidence showing that work was recently performed may answer those questions.
What If You Were Injured When a Subway Train Suddenly Stopped?
Public transportation necessarily involves ordinary starts, stops, and movements. When a passenger is injured after a particularly abrupt or unusual movement, the circumstances of that movement become important.
Our investigation may consider what caused the stop, whether the operator was responding to an emergency, how the train was being operated, whether other passengers were affected, and whether operational or mechanical evidence explains what happened.
Independent passengers who experienced the same movement may provide valuable evidence about whether the event was substantially different from the ordinary movement riders should expect aboard a subway train.
Subway Platform and Station Accidents Require Different Evidence
Falls and other accidents may result from broken walking surfaces, defective stairs, inadequate handrails, slippery conditions, construction hazards, poor lighting, falling materials, or malfunctioning station equipment. These cases often turn on notice and control.
Who maintained the location? Did the responsible party create the hazard? Was there a prior complaint? How long had the condition existed? Was an inspection required? Was a contractor working nearby?
Those questions help distinguish a genuine negligence claim from an accident for which the transit authority or another defendant had no reasonable opportunity to prevent the harm.
What Injuries Can Result From Subway Accidents?
Subway accidents can result in fractures, torn ligaments, neck and back injuries, nerve damage, crush injuries, burns, and other trauma. A passenger who strikes their head may also suffer a concussion or more serious traumatic brain injury, with symptoms that continue long after the accident.
The significance of an injury is not measured solely by the initial diagnosis. Surgery, rehabilitation, inability to work, permanent restrictions, chronic pain, and future medical needs can substantially change the consequences of an accident.
What Compensation Can You Recover After a Subway Accident?
Compensation should account for both the financial losses already caused by the accident and losses reasonably expected in the future.
| Type of Damage | What It Can Address |
|---|---|
| Medical expenses | Hospital care, surgery, specialists, rehabilitation, medication, and future treatment |
| Lost earnings | Income and employment benefits lost during recovery |
| Reduced earning capacity | Long-term inability to return to the same work or earning level |
| Pain and suffering | Physical pain and the effect of the injury on everyday life |
| Future damages | Ongoing medical, employment, and personal consequences of a permanent injury |
The value of your claim depends on the evidence. Medical records can establish diagnosis and treatment, while employment and financial records document income losses. Serious permanent injuries may require expert analysis to explain future care or diminished earning capacity.
What If the Transit Authority Says You Caused the Accident?
New York follows a pure comparative negligence rule. Being partly responsible for an accident does not automatically eliminate your right to recover damages, although your compensation can be reduced according to your percentage of fault.
Insurers may try to shift blame in subway cases by arguing that a passenger failed to use a handrail, was distracted, ignored a warning, or otherwise contributed to the incident. Our attorneys do not simply accept that characterization.
We push back against unfounded blame-shifting by using surveillance footage, photographs, witness statements, measurements, maintenance records, and the physical condition of the station or train, because they provide a more complete account of what occurred.
SCHEDULE A CONSULTATIONHow Long Do You Have to Sue After an NYC Subway Accident?
Although New York generally provides three years for many negligence lawsuits against private defendants, claims involving public transit entities can be subject to much shorter procedural deadlines. As discussed above, a required Notice of Claim generally must be served within 90 days.
The particular public authority involved also matters. New York's Public Authorities Law contains authority-specific requirements, including shortened periods for commencing certain personal injury actions after the claim accrues.
If both public and private defendants may share responsibility, different requirements can apply within the same case. The safest approach is to have an attorney determine the defendants and applicable deadlines as soon as possible rather than trying to identify the correct filing period yourself.
Why Trial Readiness Matters in a Transit Injury Case
Public authority litigation can be vigorously defended. A transit defendant may contest how the accident happened, deny notice of a dangerous condition, dispute responsibility for the location, blame a contractor or passenger, or challenge whether the injuries were caused by the incident.
At Hach & Rose, LLP, we develop liability evidence rather than relying solely on an incident report, obtaining records that establish notice or control, documenting the full medical and financial impact of the injuries, taking depositions, working with appropriate experts, and testing the defense's position through litigation.
Our founders, Michael A. Rose and Gregory Hach, built the firm around representing injured New Yorkers against defendants with substantial resources. Hach & Rose, LLP has recovered more than $1 billion for clients, and our lawyers are prepared to take cases to verdict when a defendant will not agree to a fair resolution.
That trial posture matters before trial, too. Negotiations are different when the other side knows the attorneys presenting the claim are prepared to put the evidence before a jury.
What Should You Do After a Subway Accident?
Your health comes first. Seek appropriate medical care and make sure providers understand how the injury occurred.
If you can safely do so, document the station, train, staircase, platform, or other condition involved. Record the station name, subway line, time, direction of travel, train or car information if available, and names or contact information for witnesses. Report the incident and retain any documentation you receive.
Then speak with our team promptly, particularly if a public transit entity may be responsible. The 90-day Notice of Claim period can begin running while you are still undergoing treatment.
Our New York personal injury attorneys can evaluate the accident, identify potential defendants, preserve evidence, and determine which filing requirements apply. For incidents involving other rail systems or circumstances beyond the NYC subway, see our page about New York train accidents.
Frequently Asked Questions About NYC Subway Accident Claims
Can I sue if I slipped on water in a subway station?
Potentially. A successful claim requires evidence establishing responsibility for the condition, actual or constructive notice of it, and sufficient opportunity to address the hazard. The source of the water, how long it was present, inspection practices, and surveillance evidence may become important.
What if I didn't report the accident before leaving the station?
Failing to make an immediate report does not necessarily eliminate a claim. Other evidence may establish when, where, and how the accident occurred. However, reporting the incident promptly can create useful documentation.
What happens if I miss the 90-day Notice of Claim deadline?
New York law permits courts to authorize a late Notice of Claim in certain circumstances, but permission is not automatic. Whether late notice is possible depends on the facts, which is another reason to consult an attorney immediately rather than assuming the deadline can be extended.
How much does it cost to hire Hach & Rose, LLP?
Your initial consultation is free. We handle personal injury cases on a contingency-fee basis, meaning attorney's fees are collected from the recovery rather than charged upfront. If we do not obtain a recovery, you do not owe us an attorney's fee.
Speak With an NYC Subway Accident Lawyer at Hach & Rose, LLP
A subway injury case can involve filing a 90-day notice, identifying all potential defendants, following public-authority procedures, and gathering evidence that can disappear long before the lawsuit reaches a courtroom. Hach & Rose, LLP handles that work for you.
Our NYC subway accident attorneys investigate what happened, identify who was responsible, preserve transit and medical evidence, calculate the full extent of your losses, negotiate from a position of strength, and take cases to trial when necessary.
Hach & Rose, LLP has recovered $1 billion+ for our injured clients. If you were seriously injured aboard a subway train or at an unsafe station or platform, call (212) 779-0057 or contact us online for a free, confidential consultation. Our team is available 24/7, and we offer case reviews in English and Spanish.
SCHEDULE A CONSULTATION