Skip to content

Over One Billion Recovered

Free Confidential Case Review, No Fees Unless We Recover For You

Call Us Today 212-779-0057

Hach & Rose, LLP Logo
  • The Firm
    • About Us
    • News
    • FAQs
    • Press Releases
    • Scholarship
    • Must Know Info
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury
      • Car Accidents
      • Truck Accidents
      • Motorcycle Accidents
      • Premises Liability
      • Slip and Fall Accidents
      • Nursing Home Abuse
      • Brain Injuries
      • Neck and Back Injuries
      • Construction Accidents
      • Scooter Accidents
      • Fires and Explosions
      • FELA/Railroad Worker Injuries
      • Rental Bike Accidents
      • New York City Sexual Abuse Lawyer
      • Tourist Injuries
      • Work Injuries
      • New York City Wrongful Death Lawyer
      • See all personal injury practice areas
    • Mass Tort Cases
      • Suboxone Lawsuit
      • Social Media Harm
      • Ozempic Lawsuit
      • Video Game Addiction
      • Hair Straightener Uterine Cancer Lawsuit
      • Pacemaker Recall Lawsuit
      • Paraquat Lawsuit
      • Talcum Powder Lawsuit
      • Baby Formula Lawsuit
      • Asbestos
      • See All Defective Drugs & Products
    • Construction Injuries
      • Representation for Union Members
      • FELA / Railroad Worker Injury
      • See All Work Related Injuries
    • Social Security Disability
  • Video FAQs
  • Testimonials
  • Results
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Search
Get a free consultation

How Do Car Accident Settlements Work?

Home  >  Blog  >  How Do Car Accident Settlements Work?

March 24, 2025 | By Hach & Rose, LLP
How Do Car Accident Settlements Work?

A car accident can leave an injured victim with mounting medical bills, lost earnings, and significant pain and discomfort. State law allows injury victims to obtain compensation for their injuries and damages if another party causes the accident. Usually, a car accident claim is settled out of court with a settlement. How does a car accident settlement work? Keep reading to find out more. Then, talk to an auto accident attorney to learn if you have a viable case.

What Is A Car Accident Settlement?

A car accident settlement is a negotiated legal agreement between the injury victim, the liable party, or their insurance company. The parties agree on a certain sum being paid for the plaintiff’s injuries and damages, signed by both. Unfortunately, settling a car accident claim with the insurance company without an attorney is usually unwise. Several things can happen with a car accident settlement if you don’t hire a car accident attorney to represent you:

You Say Something That Damages Your Claim

The other driver’s insurance adjuster calls you after an accident. They ask if you are ok. You say, sure, I’m fine. Just an innocent phrase can be used to deny your claim later. The insurance company will call you only to use what you say against you. It’s always better to decline to talk to the other driver’s insurance company. Provide the insurance adjuster with your attorney’s contact information.

The Offer Is Too Low

The insurance company works for the other party, aiming to pay as little as possible for your losses. Without an attorney representing you, there’s a good chance the insurance adjuster will offer less than you deserve. Most injury victims don’t understand the full value of their claim. Hiring a skilled car accident lawyer to represent you means they’ll negotiate a fair settlement. The settlement demand your attorney makes will be based on documented losses you have, including medical bills, lost earnings, pain and suffering, and mental anguish.

You Sign Too Soon

Suppose you negotiate a car accident settlement with the other driver’s insurance company without hiring a lawyer. You thought you had $5,000 in medical bills, but a month later, you discovered that you needed a $10,000 surgery for a back problem related to a car accident. But you signed the release form, and it’s too late to get more money. A car accident lawyer will not settle a claim before knowing you are at maximum medical recovery. This means that your injuries have fully healed or have healed as much as possible.

You Are Permanently Disabled

Unfortunately, some auto accident victims sign a settlement without a lawyer, only to discover later that their injury leaves them permanently disabled. You cannot return to get more money for lost earning capacity and medical bills. You should always have a car accident attorney represent you if there is a significant injury.

You Get Blamed For The Accident

The other party’s insurance company can try to blame you partially for the accident and lower their settlement offer. Unacceptable. Always hire an auto accident attorney if there is any question about accident liability. Fortunately, these problems can be avoided easily after a serious auto accident caused by another party. Contact a car accident attorney to handle your car accident claim.

What Happens In A Car Accident Claim?

You may be entitled to compensation if another party’s negligence caused the car accident and injuries. If you live in a no-fault state, like New York for example, the first step is to always file a claim with your insurance company. Every driver in no-fault states must purchase Personal Injury Protection (PIP) insurance that covers your initial damages for medical expenses and lost earnings, regardless of fault. You may be eligible to file a personal injury lawsuit if your damages exceed your no-fault coverage. Still, it is essential to determine who is at fault in the car accident to ensure there is a fair settlement. The next steps in the car accident claim process are:

Hire A Car Accident Attorney

You should always retain a car accident attorney if another party’s negligence caused the car accident. Your attorney will review your case in a free consultation to understand your legal options.

Investigate The Case

The car accident lawyer will investigate the accident to determine who caused it. They will review all major evidence, including police reports, witness statements, medical records, photos and videos from the crash scene, surveillance video footage, etc. Your car accident attorney will analyze the crash evidence to build the strongest case for compensation. This is important in a no-fault state because your claim must exceed certain thresholds to file a personal injury lawsuit to obtain your full damages.

Calculate Damages

You may be entitled to compensation for your losses beyond what your PIP insurance covers. This can include compensation for medical bills, lost earnings, pain and suffering, and mental anguish.

Negotiate With The Insurance Company

Once you have filed your accident claim with your insurance company, it should pay for your initial damages with your PIP insurance. Your attorney can deal with your insurance company to ensure you receive the best loss settlement.

File A Personal Injury Lawsuit

If your auto insurance claim doesn’t cover all your damages, you can sue the liable party for additional damages. An experienced auto accident attorney can provide representation in court and prepare your case for trial.

Who May Be At Fault In A Car Accident?

Recovering compensation beyond your PIP insurance in a no-fault state means knowing who is at fault for the auto accident. There are several potential liable parties for car accidents, depending on the circumstances:

Negligent Driver

Other drivers cause most auto accidents. Drivers may be texting, fatigued, distracted by other means, or under the influence. Talk to your car accident attorney if you think the other driver was under the influence of drugs or alcohol.

Dram Shops

These are restaurants, bars, and nightclubs that serve alcohol. Dram shops in many states can be held responsible for a drunk driving accident if they served someone who was already intoxicated. Suing a bar or restaurant may ensure you receive fair compensation for your injuries.

Auto Parts Company

If a car or car part is defective and causes a car accident, the company can be held accountable for a product liability claim. A personal injury attorney can assist you with filing a product liability lawsuit.

Government Agency

Government agencies may be liable for an accident if a road defect or construction zone hazard contributed to a car accident. Retaining a car accident attorney is even more critical if a company or government agency may be liable. These are complex auto accident claims that require the knowledge of an experienced personal injury attorney.

How Do You Calculate The Value Of Your Car Accident Claim?

Your attorney must value your case accurately. When another person’s negligence caused your injuries, you are entitled to compensation for your losses. You must be paid for every way the accident negatively affected your life. Some of the damages you can receive in your claim include:

Medical Expenses

You can receive compensation for your current and future medical expenses, such as ER and ambulatory costs, surgeries, hospitalization, home modifications, physical therapy, medical devices, etc. One of your attorney’s roles is to accurately estimate your future medical bills. They will interview your medical team and document your prognosis and future medical requirements. That way, it is ensured that you receive enough money for your medical needs. Your medical bill compensation will be higher for a severe injury, such as brain trauma, spinal cord damage, severe burns, amputations, disfigurement, etc.

Lost Earnings

You may receive compensation for your past, current, and future lost earnings related to the accident and medical treatments. For example, you should receive compensation for your doctor’s appointments, surgeries, and hospitalizations if you missed work. Furthermore, a severe injury may entitle you to lost earning capacity if you cannot return to work. Someone with a paralysis injury, for example, may be unable to work in the future. You should receive compensation for the years of lost income you will have based on your previous salary or earnings.

Pain And Suffering

Some compensation is more complicated to calculate, and pain and suffering are examples. You can have severe pain from shattered bones from a car accident. This pain has a monetary value, but the insurance company may try to pay less than you deserve. Your attorney will advocate for the most compensation based on medical information from your doctors about your injuries and pain.

Mental And Emotional Trauma

Imagine losing an arm or leg in a severe truck accident. You will never be the same. Not only is the injury physically painful, it’s mentally and emotionally traumatic. You should receive compensation for your emotional suffering. A car accident attorney may obtain information from your mental health providers to document how the loss affects you mentally. A severe physical loss, such as paralysis or an amputation, will be worth more in a car accident settlement than a less severe injury.

Scarring And Disfigurement

A severe injury, such as burns in a tractor-trailer accident, can cause scarring and disfigurement to visible parts of the body. Your attorney will fight for just compensation for this injury.

What Is A ‘Serious Injury’ In A No-Fault State?

We explained earlier that your PIP insurance will pay your initial damages in a no-fault state. There are limited cases in which you can file a personal injury lawsuit in a no-fault state, such as New York. This is if you have a "serious injury" that is defined as:
  • A disability that lasts for more than 90 days
  • A bone fracture
  • Loss of fetus
  • Major disfigurement, such as facial burns
  • Permanent disability, such as organ damage or limited use of a body part
You should talk to your auto accident attorney to learn if you can file a personal injury lawsuit against the liable party.

Your Car Accident Attorney Can Handle a No-Fault Claim

Your insurance company may pay you less than you deserve for your settlement if you do not have strong legal advocacy. A car accident attorney understands the complex no-fault rules for your state. Being legally informed can affect the settlement you receive. Also, you should always retain an attorney for your claim if you have a serious injury or losses over $25,000.

How Long Does A Car Accident Settlement Take?

Most injury victims have financial losses after a serious auto accident. Getting a settlement check quickly is a priority. How long it takes to happen depends on many factors. First, how severe was the auto accident? A severe crash with devastating injuries can entail hundreds of thousands or millions in compensation. Such claims take longer to settle because considerable money is on the line. Second, who is at fault? A simple case of one car rear-ending another usually means that one driver is to blame for the accident. However, a 10-car pileup on an interstate can have several liable parties. It will take time for the various attorneys and insurance companies to sort it out. Also, a company being liable for an accident can lead to a longer settlement negotiation because multiple entities and insurance companies can be involved. Third, which insurance companies are liable? Some insurance companies settle faster than others. Some may contest a claim more vigorously and even be willing to go to court. Always have an auto accident attorney review your car accident claim to understand your legal options. The consultation is free, and there’s no obligation.

Contact A Car Accident Attorney Today

A car accident attorney should be consulted if you were in an accident through no fault of your own. You can be owed compensation for your medical expenses and losses. Talk to an auto accident attorney in your area today for a complimentary consultation. This means you can get the information and advice you need without any financial obligation. Call today.

Schedule Your Consultation

Practice Areas

  • New York City Subway Accident Lawyer
  • New York Motorcycle Accidents Caused by Driver Error Lawyer
  • New York Road Defect Motorcycle Accident Lawyers
  • New York Drunk Driving Motorcycle Accident Attorney
  • New York Driver Error Lawyers
  • New York Overweight Load Lawyers
  • New York Truck Accidents Due to Poor Road Conditions Lawyer
  • New York Aggressive Truck Driving Accidents Lawyer
  • Bus Accidents
  • New York Rideshare Accident Lawyer
  • New York Hit and Run Lawyer
  • New York Burns Suffered in Car Accidents Lawyer
  • New York Disfigurement from Car Accidents Lawyer
  • New York Fatigued Driving Car Accidents Lawyers
  • New York Lawyer for Car Accidents Caused By Speeding
  • New York Tailgating Accident Lawyer
  • New York Lawyers for Loss of Limb in a Car Accident
  • New York Car Seat Ejection Injury Lawyer
  • New York Crush Injuries from a Car Accident Lawyer
  • New York Paralysis After a Car Accident Lawyer
  • Car Accidents
  • New York Internal Bleeding from Car Accidents Lawyer
  • New York Soft Tissue Injuries from Car Accidents Lawyers
  • New York Concussions from Car Accidents Lawyer
  • New York Attorneys for Lacerations and Disfigurement from Car Accidents
  • Aviation Accidents
  • New York City Train Accident Lawyer
  • Electric Scooter Accident Lawyer in New York
  • New York Truck Accident Lawyer
  • New York Motorcycle Accident Lawyer
  • New York Car Accident Lawyer
  • Car Accidents

free consultation for personal injury lawsuits

Frequently Asked Questions for New York Personal Injury Lawyers

Our attorneys in New York offer free consultations to injured victims and their families. You can call us at 212-779-0057 to make an appointment.

Get a free consultation

Am I able to recover lost wages or medical bills?

An experienced injury attorney can help you to seek and recover various damages like loss of income and medical bills, depending on the nature of the claim. Personal injury accident victims in New York, NY should contact a lawyer at Hach and Rose for a free case evaluation.

I'm one of several surviving family members. Can I file a claim on behalf of the injured party in New York, NY?

If you're a family member of an injured victim, you may be able to file a lawsuit on behalf of the victim. Contact us today at (646) 766-1670 to discuss your case.

Is there a fee if I don't win the case?

Our personal injury lawyers in New York, NY, do not charge any fees unless we obtain compensation for our clients.

Do I really need an attorney for a simple motor vehicle accident?

If you've been injured or have lost a loved one in a motor vehicle accident, regardless of the circumstances, it's important to speak with a personal injury attorney as soon as possible. Accidents involving motor vehicles can be complex and require an attorney to investigate the details surrounding the incident. Call us today at (646) 766-1670 for a free evaluation.

I have a permanent injury. How do I pursue compensation against someone for that person's negligent actions?

If you have a permanent injury, your personal injury lawyer can discuss the different options for compensation with you. Our personal injury lawyers in New York, NY, are prepared to help victims just like you. To schedule a free appointment with one of our personal injury attorneys, call (646) 766-1670 today.

My child had a birth injury. Is this the fault of the medical professionals? Am I entitled to financial compensation?

If a medical professional failed to properly diagnose or treat an injury during the birthing process, this might be grounds for a claim. In addition, our birth injury attorneys in New York state can help you to file a lawsuit on behalf of your child if there was any inappropriate or negligent behavior from medical staff that resulted in injury or death, also known as medical malpractice.

In addition to my permanent injuries, I suffer from emotional distress related to the accident. What is the legal process to getting full and fair compensation?

Our experienced New York personal injury lawyers can file a claim for emotional distress caused by the negligence of another. Contact us at (646) 766-1670 for more information about how we can help you seek full compensation

I'm not sure if I need a lawyer. Do you offer other forms of legal assistance?

Our personal injury attorneys in New York, NY, can help you to explore your legal options for different types of claims. We offer free consultations where you can discuss your claim with one of our experienced accident lawyers. Call us or fill out the form on our website to get started.

My insurance company will not pay for my medical bills after a serious injury. Can you help me?

No insurance company should deny an injured victim of medical negligence proper compensation. A New York injury and accident attorney works with victims and their families to file a lawsuit against negligent parties to seek compensation for injuries and damages.

Where are you located in New York City?

The law office of Hach & Rose, LLP is located at 112 Madison Ave, 10th Floor, New York, NY 10016

How do I know if I have a New York personal injury case?

An experienced accident lawyer can help you to determine if you have a valid claim. To schedule a free case evaluation with one of our accident attorneys in New York, NY, call (646) 766-1670.

Helping Victims Get Justice In New York

A New York law firm, working on behalf of New Yorkers

Hach & Rose, LLP, is proud to offer completely free consultations to our clients with no obligations or strings attached. Our personal injury law firm has multilingual support, and we work on behalf of our clients nationwide. Hach & Rose is not just a single experienced injury lawyer but rather a team of attorneys who work together to handle personal injury claims and personal injury lawsuits. Please call our law firm at (646) 374-4158 or spend a couple of seconds completing the contact form online. We are dedicated to our clients, and in the event that you contact us after office hours, we commit to responding to you quickly.

Get a free consultation
Hach & Rose, LLP Logo If you've been injured in an accident or on the job, the attorneys of Hach & Rose, LLP have the knowledge, skills, and experience required to hold the party responsible for your injury accountable.

Areas Served: Bronx, Brooklyn, Bushwick, Brooklyn Heights, Central Harlem, East Harlem, East Village, Financial District, Greenpoint, Forest Hills, Harlem, Howard Beach, Jackson Heights, Lower East Side, Lower Manhattan, Manhattan, Midtown, New Jersey, Rego Park, Soho, Tribeca, Upper East Side, Upper Manhattan, Upper West Side, West Side, West Harlem

Main Office

Hach & Rose, LLP

112 Madison Ave 10th floor,
New York, NY 10016
212-779-0057

Schedule Your Free Consultation

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Consent agreement*


  • The Firm
  • Practice Areas
  • Video FAQs
  • Testimonials
  • Results
  • Blog
  • Contact

© 2025 Hach & Rose, LLP. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Sitemap